top of page

True Crime Chronicles: US Deputy Marshal and his posse were killed in 1894 while serving a warrant in Sequoyah County

Writer: Dennis McCaslin
Dennis McCaslin
6 minutes ago
3 min read


On a warm Friday night in September 1894, the house of young John Seabolt sat seven miles from Muldrow in the Sequoyah District of the Cherokee Nation, a short walk from his father’s place and about twenty miles west of Fort Smith.


Music and voices carried across the yard as a dance filled the rooms. Men and women gathered under lamplight, the usual mix of neighbors, travelers, and those who preferred the edge of the law. Among them that evening was a man known only as Bush, wanted on a federal warrant.


Deputy United States Marshal West Harris, a white man and adopted citizen of the Cherokee Nation, rode to the Seabolt place with his posse, Frank Faulkner. Harris had previously ridden posse with Deputy Marshal Jim Cole out of Fort Smith. Faulkner was twenty-four, from a good family, yet the Cherokee Advocate would later note he turned dangerous when liquor took hold.


Months earlier he had left the country, certain that if he stayed he would kill someone or be killed. He had been back less than a week.


Harris carried the warrant for Bush. During the evening, he spotted the man in the yard. The two lawmen moved to make the arrest. What followed was a close, savage fight.



When the smoke cleared, three men lay dead in the yard, each with an empty pistol. Harris had taken one shot to the chest and still gripped his pistol. Faulkner had been hit seven times, including shotgun wounds; his empty pistol lay about ten yards from his body. Charlie Benge, a Cherokee well known in Fort Smith who had once ridden as a posse for the federal court, was shot once through the body, his empty gun still in his hand. Two more bodies were found under the house.



Word reached Fort Smith. The next morning Deputy Marshal Jim Cole rode out to investigate. The three named dead still lay where they had fallen. Cole found only one man who admitted being at the dance: Seabolt’s father, so drunk he remembered nothing of the fight.


The women said they could tell nothing. No other witness would speak. John Seabolt and his cousin Bean Seabolt had already left. They had ridden to Webb’s store, bought cartridges, and told the storekeeper there had been a little trouble, that four of the bullies were laid out, and that they thought they would keep out of trouble by leaving.


They were not seen again.


Old grudges were presumed. That was as far as the record went. No indictment followed. The file closed before the week ended. No one was ever charged.


Faulkner was buried the next afternoon at Lee’s Chapel Cemetery in Muldrow. Harris’s grave has never been identified. The man called Bush, the two men under the house, and the precise order of the first shots never entered any surviving official account.


The Cherokee Advocate in Tahlequah printed the story on September 26, drawing on the Fort Smith News Record. That clipping, along with later memorial listings, remains the core public record.


This was Cherokee Nation land in 1894. Federal deputies from Judge Isaac Parker’s court in Fort Smith held jurisdiction over United States citizens and certain crimes. Cherokee courts held jurisdiction over Cherokee citizens.


A dance that mixed an adopted citizen, a Cherokee former posse, a wanted man known only as Bush, and a local family left Cole with empty guns, five bodies, and silence. In the Indian Territory of that era, such nights were not rare. Deputies worked for fees, rode long miles, and often met resistance that left no clear witness and no conviction.


The Sequoyah Tragedy of September 14, 1894, stands as one of those nights: a warrant served, a dance interrupted, five men dead, and the truth left in the yard with the empty pistols.


 
 

©2024 Today in Fort Smith. 

bottom of page