top of page

Our Arklahoma Heroes: An Adair County soldier was among the casualties at the Battle of Leyte in 1944

Writer: Dennis McCaslin
Dennis McCaslin
10 hours ago
2 min read

in the quiet rows of Proctor Cemetery, the stone sits low against the grass, its face reading Arthur Gustiv Crittenden, S2 US Navy WW II KIA, with the dates November 21, 1924 to October 25, 1944. The lettering is simple and the surrounding markers carry other Crittenden names, among them his father Jackson and his mother Mary Ann Elizabeth Brantley.


On the Adair County memorial near the Stilwell courthouse the same man appears under a slightly different rendering, AUTHUR GUSTIN CRITTENDEN, one name among the county’s World War II dead. Both inscriptions mark a life that began in the hills of Adair County and ended at sea in the western Pacific.


He was born in the Proctor area on November 21, 1924, the son of Jack Crittenden and Mary Ann Elizabeth Brantley Crittenden. The family lived in a community dense with Crittenden kin, many of them buried in the same cemetery that would later hold his memorial stone. Jackson Crittenden died in 1930 when Arthur was still a boy.


Mary Ann Elizabeth remained in Proctor and became the next of kin listed on official Navy records, her address given as General Delivery, Proctor, Oklahoma. When war came she would receive the telegram that confirmed her son would not come home.



Arthur entered the U.S. Naval Reserve as a teenager and reached the rating of Seaman Second Class. His serial number appears in the Oklahoma Navy casualty summary as 8498255. Like many young men from rural Adair County, including those from Cherokee communities around Proctor, he left the hills for the Pacific.


Public records do not name the ship or unit that carried him on October 25, 1944. That date falls in the middle of the Battle of Leyte Gulf and the broader fighting for the Philippines. Navy state summaries list him among Oklahoma’s Navy, Marine, and Coast Guard dead. His remains were never recovered.

The American Battle Monuments Commission placed his name on the Walls of the Missing at the Manila American Cemetery in the Philippines, the standard overseas memorial for sailors lost at sea or in unrecovered Pacific actions. The Purple Heart that accompanies such losses is noted in the honor rolls that record his death.


Local memory kept a parallel record. In 1992 Adair County dedicated its war memorial and included his name among those who died in the Second World War. At Proctor Cemetery the family stone repeats the essential facts: Seaman Second Class, United States Navy, World War II, killed in action. No lengthy obituary has surfaced in open newspaper archives.


Mary Ann Elizabeth Crittenden lived until 1960. She is buried at Proctor Cemetery near the memorial that carries her son’s name. The hills around Proctor still hold the families that sent young men into the Navy and the Army in those years.


Arthur Gustiv Crittenden’s short service ended on a day when the Pacific Fleet was engaged across the Philippine approaches. His serial number, his rating, his mother’s address, and the two local inscriptions continue to mark the point where one Adair County life met the larger history of that autumn.


 
 

©2024 Today in Fort Smith. 

bottom of page