top of page

Cold Case Files: US Deputy Marshal John Zeke holds the distinction of being the first lawman killed from Westerm District

Writer: Dennis McCaslin
Dennis McCaslin
11 hours ago
3 min read

On a raw February night in 1872, in a place that barely qualified as a town, a young deputy staggered out of the dark toward the Muskogee railway station with a bullet in his chest.


John Zeke was about twenty-one, born in Missouri, and had not been wearing a badge long enough for anyone to remember much about him beyond the fact that he carried one for the Western District of Arkansas. By the time they got him to the Pioneer Hotel and a doctor arrived, he was already dying.


Before he went, he managed to say that he had arrested a man tied to the theft of the express chest when several teamsters stepped in and shot him.



The chest had been emptied the night before. Charles Goodard, brought in drunk by the night clerk and watchman to sleep it off in the station offices, left after an hour. Shortly afterward someone found the express box unlocked and six hundred two dollars gone.


Goodard was picked up the next morning with two hundred forty-four dollars still on him and hauled to Fort Gibson to wait for the trip to Fort Smith. Around eleven o’clock the following night the shots came. Zeke never made it back inside under his own power.


Muskogee was weeks old. The Missouri, Kansas and Texas Railroad had crossed the Arkansas River on the first of January and planted a station a mile and a half south of the bank. Tents, shacks, freighters with ox teams, railroad hands, whiskey sellers, and men with no fixed address had poured in behind the tracks.


There was no safe in the express office and almost no law beyond whatever a deputy could enforce on foot or horseback. The Territory west of Fort Smith had always been hard ground, but the railroad had turned this stretch of the Creek Nation into something sharper and more crowded overnight. Zeke became the first deputy known to die in it.


A posse formed and rode after the teamsters. No one was ever charged. The records simply stop. On the seventeenth he was buried at Fort Gibson National Cemetery. The handwritten ledger called him Zeek. Someone carving the stone misread the name and cut “John Beck.”


That marker stood for nearly a century and a half until a replacement finally gave him his own name and the words U.S. Marshals Service.


Six days later another deputy, William Bentz, was shot down while serving a warrant in the Cherokee Nation. In April a larger posse rode into the Going Snake district and walked into a courtroom shootout that killed eight of them.


The numbers climbed for the next thirty-five years until more than a hundred men who rode for the Fort Smith court had died between the Arkansas line and the western edge of the Territory. Zeke’s name sits at the front of that list, the first entry in a ledger that grew long enough to shock even the people who kept it.


He left almost nothing else. No photograph, no detailed appointment papers that survived in plain view, no family that later claimed him in the public record.


His legacy is the dying statement, the empty express chest, the misspelled stone, and the simple fact that the deadliest assignment in the history of the Marshals Service began with a twenty-one-year-old deputy walking into a railroad station on a night when the tracks were still new and the town was still mostly canvas.



 
 

©2024 Today in Fort Smith. 

bottom of page