True Crime Chronicles: The body of 22-year-old John Rogers was concealed beneath a haystack in 1920

In the Tri-State Mining District, where fortunes were dug from the earth and men disappeared as easily as dust on the wind, a young farmer’s life ended beneath a pile of straw in Craig County in 1920.

More than a century later, the killing of John Rogers remains one of northeast Oklahoma’s most haunting unsolved mysteries.

On the night of November 5, 1920, John Rogers vanished. The 22-year-old had been seen only days earlier in Chetopa, Kansas, purchasing a revolve, his first and last firearm purchase. He told friends he was headed to Picher to chase work in the lead and zinc mines, a rite of passage for countless young men of the era.

One of the last people to speak with him was 18-year-old Clifton Hurst, a neighbor who later recalled a casual conversation about mining jobs. Then, silence.

Three weeks passed. Whispers turned to worry. On a frigid December afternoon, a farmer near Welch noticed something odd at the edge of his haystack: the straw was matted, as if something heavy had been dragged across the ground.

Beneath the pile lay John Roger, dead, rigid, and hidden .Two .38-caliber bullets had torn through his left breast. Physicians later said either wound would have killed him instantly.

The new revolver lay at his side, two shells spent. A scorched hole, one-and-a-half inches wide, burned into his shirt from the muzzle blast, proof the shots were fired at point-blank range. Strangest of all: his vest was fully buttoned, with no bullet holes in the outer garment.

The undershirt beneath bore twin perforations that lined up perfectly with the fatal wounds. Drag marks led from the nearby field to the haystack, clear evidence someone had tried to conceal the crime.

Craig County Sheriff’s deputies and County Attorney staff descended on the rural community. For days, locals were hauled in for questioning. Suspicion settled on the last known person to see Rogers alive: Clifton Hurst.

On the Saturday evening before Christmas, the teenager was arrested and charged with murder. His only “confession”? Admitting he had spoken with Rogers hours before the disappearance. No blood on his clothes. No witnesses. No motive.

Just circumstance and small-town desperation for an answer.

Hurst spent the holidays behind bars. But when the preliminary hearing convened in Vinita before Judge Frank L. Haymes, the case collapsed.

“The evidence was purely circumstantial,” the judge ruled. “There was no direct testimony to connect the young man with the murder except his own admission that he was with the murdered boy a short time before his disappearance.”

Clifton Hurst walked free, exonerated, but forever branded by suspicion.

The dismissal left authorities with nothing. Assistant County Attorney Roper vowed to continue the hunt, insisting the killers (note the plural_ were local residents. He drew a chilling parallel to another unsolved slaying five years earlier, when a man named Peel was gunned down in the same district.

Yet no new leads surfaced.

The trail went cold faster than an Oklahoma norther. John Rogers’ pistol, his buttoned vest, the scorched shirt, and the haystack that became his grave, all remain frozen in yellowed newspaper clippings.

The case file, if it ever existed in full, has long since vanished from Craig County courthouse shelves.

\

In the end, the haystack hid more than a body. It concealed the truth. Was Rogers killed in a mining-camp grudge? A robbery gone wrong? A personal betrayal buried deeper than any shaft in Picher?

The prairie kept its secret, and the slayer, whether one man or severa, melted into the transient tide of boomtown life.

More than a hundred years later, John Rogers is still waiting for justice beneath the Oklahoma stars.