top of page

The Bottom Line: Words have meaning and just because you can say something doesn't always mean you should

  • Writer: Dennis McCaslin
    Dennis McCaslin
  • Sep 22, 2025
  • 3 min read

Recently, Madison County resident Jay Brown decided to take aim at Today in Fort Smith, blasting our reporting on the Jason Lierl case and tossing around words like “fake news” and “creative writing.”


Let’s be clear: Brown’s tantrum has less to do with facts and more to do with protecting his own reputation. And libelous words are often the downfall of slanderous bullies.


Because when you strip away the noise, Jay Brown isn’t a credible watchdog. He’s a disgraced ex-cop with a felony record and a long trail of paranoia-filled messages that tell you everything you need to know about his motives.


Brown is not the fearless crusader he pretends to be on Facebook. He is a former Elkins police officer who pled guilty to felony charges for the unauthorized release of criminal history records. That conviction cost him his law enforcement certification permanently. He walked away with probation, fines, and a criminal record.


His résumé also includes threats and harassment -- hardly the track record of someone the public should trust as an authority on law enforcement or journalism.


While calling us “fake news,” Brown has spent months spinning his own stories in private messages. Here are just a few gems from Brown’s own words:

“If Ronnie and Robert [Boyd] are cousins then Ronnie’s not running s*** and the Madison County Sheriff’s Department is being run by Robert Boyd through Ronnie by proxy.”
“Evidence was given to Madison County… It is believed that evidence never was checked into the evidence locker… I think it’s likely the evidence was destroyed.”
“McLaughlin has an MO. He likes to sexually assault unconscious women… His two favorite things in the world are roofies and chloroform.”
“Clint was actively on methamphetamine while he was a deputy. While he was the county’s K9 Handler and narcotics officer.”

These aren’t facts. They’re rambling accusations, stitched together with rumor, innuendo, and “someone told me” speculation. In one breath, Brown paints half of Madison County law enforcement as drug addicts, rapists, or puppets of Robert Boyd.


In the next, he rants about FBI conspiracies and “too big to fail” coverups.

And yet --he dares to accuse Today in Fort Smith of “creative writing”?


The truth is, Jay Brown isn’t exposing corruption -- he’s projecting. His career collapsed because of poor judgment, misconduct, and a felony conviction. He lost his badge, his credibility, and his standing in law enforcement. Now he hides behind social media, pretending he’s still relevant by tearing down others.


When he calls us “fake,” what he’s really doing is rewriting his own history.


The public deserves facts, not Facebook rants. That’s why Today in Fort Smith will continue to report on corruption, negligence, and misconduct -- whether the guilty parties wear badges, carry microphones, or, like Jay Brown, try to resurrect their reputations by slinging mud at journalists.


Brown can rant all he wants. He can accuse, deflect, and spin. But the record doesn’t lie:

  • He is a former cop.

  • He broke the law.

  • He lost his certification.

  • And now, he’s trying to rewrite his own story.


We’ll keep doing our job. And the louder Jay Brown gets, the more obvious it becomes why our work matters. It's about integrity and accountability, two words unknown to a wannabe crime fighter.


And if it's "creative writing" you're after, take a gander at some of this reckless prose:




 
 

©2024 Today in Fort Smith. 

bottom of page